• Meal Plans
  • Recipes
  • My Meal Plan
Sign InSign Up

We are here to help save time and money on your weekly grocery shop.

© Copyright 2026 Supermenu. All Rights Reserved.

About
  • Blog
  • Contact
Legal
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
Apr 12, 2024

Recipe Boxes vs Meal Planning: The Real Cost Comparison

We break down exactly what you're paying for with recipe box subscriptions—and how much you could save with supermarket shopping.

Cover Image for Recipe Boxes vs Meal Planning: The Real Cost Comparison

Recipe box services have transformed how millions of people cook. No more wondering what to make. No more missing ingredients. Just pick your recipes, wait for the box, and follow the instructions.

It's a brilliant solution to a genuine problem. But it's also an expensive one. Let's look at the actual numbers.

What recipe boxes really cost

As of 2024, here's roughly what you're paying with the major UK recipe box services:

  • Gousto: From £2.99 per serving (minimum 4 servings), typically £5-7 per serving on popular plans
  • Hello Fresh: From £3.15 per serving, typically £5-6 per serving
  • Mindful Chef: From £4.50 per serving, typically £7-9 per serving

For a family of four eating five recipe box dinners per week, that's £100-140 weekly on evening meals alone. Over a year, you're looking at £5,000-7,000 just on dinners.

What you're actually paying for

The ingredients in a recipe box aren't special. They're the same vegetables, meat, and store cupboard items you'd buy in a supermarket. So where does the money go?

Portioning. Someone has to weigh out exactly 80g of rice, 150ml of stock, and one tablespoon of ginger paste. That labour costs money.

Packaging. Every pre-portioned ingredient needs its own container or sachet. The ice packs, the insulated box, the recipe cards. All that packaging is built into the price.

Logistics. Getting fresh ingredients to your door on a specific day requires a sophisticated cold chain. Vans, drivers, refrigeration—none of it is cheap.

Marketing. Those TV ads and influencer partnerships? They're not free. The cost is baked into your subscription.

None of this is unreasonable. These are genuine services that cost money to provide. But it's worth understanding that you're paying a significant premium for convenience.

The supermarket alternative

Now let's cost out the same meals with supermarket ingredients.

Take a classic recipe box dish: Thai green chicken curry with jasmine rice. A typical recipe box serves 2 for about £12.

From a supermarket:

  • Chicken thighs (300g): £2.50
  • Thai green curry paste: £1.50 (jar makes 4+ meals)
  • Coconut milk: £1.00
  • Vegetables (peppers, mange tout): £2.00
  • Jasmine rice: £1.80 (bag makes 6+ servings)
  • Fresh herbs: £0.80

Total for first time: roughly £9.60 for 2 servings. But that curry paste and rice will last multiple meals, so the real per-meal cost drops to around £5-6.

Make the dish a second time: £5.30 for 2 servings (£2.65 per serving)—less than half the recipe box price.

The compound savings

Recipe box subscriptions keep you paying premium prices forever. Every meal costs the same, whether it's your first time making it or your fiftieth.

Supermarket shopping builds your store cupboard over time. Buy rice once, eat rice for weeks. Buy a spice rack gradually, use it for years. The more you cook, the more your per-meal costs drop.

Over a year, a family switching from recipe boxes to planned supermarket shopping can realistically save £2,000-3,000. That's a holiday. A home improvement. A significant chunk of a savings goal.

The packaging difference

Let's talk about waste. A typical recipe box generates:

  • Large cardboard box (weekly)
  • Ice packs (often not recyclable)
  • Multiple plastic sachets and pots
  • Vacuum-sealed protein containers
  • Individual vegetable packaging
  • Paper recipe cards and inserts

Multiply that by 52 weeks and you've got a small mountain of waste, much of which ends up in landfill despite best intentions.

Supermarket shopping isn't packaging-free, but it's dramatically better. Buy loose vegetables. Choose larger containers of staples. Reuse your bags. The waste reduction is immediate and visible.

When recipe boxes make sense

We're not saying recipe boxes are always wrong. They can be genuinely useful for:

  • Learning to cook in the first place
  • Breaking out of a recipe rut
  • Weeks when you genuinely have zero capacity to plan
  • Trying cuisines you're unfamiliar with

If a recipe box gets you cooking when you otherwise wouldn't, that's valuable. The issue is when subscription becomes the permanent default, and the costs quietly accumulate.

The Supermenu approach

What if you could get the planning benefits of recipe boxes without the premium pricing?

That's exactly what Supermenu offers. Browse recipes, build your weekly menu, and we'll generate a shopping list you can take to any supermarket. Same convenience, real-world prices, fraction of the packaging.

You get the "what's for dinner" question answered without the £100+ weekly bill.

See the difference for yourself. Plan your week at Supermenu.uk →